Recommendation & Moderation Policy
Last updated: October 2026
Our Approach
Born to Be Wild is built on the voices of women and parents in Portugal. Our directory exists because families deserve honest, peer-sourced information about the practitioners who support them during pregnancy, birth and the postpartum period.
Every recommendation in our directory comes from a real person describing a real experience. We believe in the value of that testimony, whether positive, nuanced or mixed, and our role is to make space for it with care, rigour and respect for everyone involved.
This policy explains how we collect, assess and publish recommendations, and how we handle disputes or removal requests.
1. What Qualifies as a Recommendation
To be published, a recommendation must:
- Be based on the submitter's own genuine, direct experience with the practitioner
- Relate to care provided in a perinatal context (pregnancy, birth, postpartum or newborn care)
- Be submitted by a real individual with a verified email address (not via automated systems)
- Contain enough substance to be informative for other parents: a general endorsement alone, without any descriptive element, may not be sufficient for publication
- Comply with our Terms of Use
We do not accept recommendations submitted by practitioners themselves, by their staff, or by individuals acting on their behalf.
2. What We Publish
When you submit a recommendation, you choose whether your written comment may be published on the practitioner's profile.
- If you agree, we may publish your written testimonial with your first name (or the nickname you provided) and the approximate period of care.
- If you do not agree, your comment is not published. It stays private and is only used by our team to inform moderation and listing decisions.
We never publish email addresses or any other contact information.
We publish positive, nuanced and mixed testimonials. A recommendation does not need to be entirely positive to be published: experiences that are partly critical are welcome, provided they are grounded in concrete, first-hand observations (for example: "consultations felt very brief" or "my birth plan was not discussed").
We do not publish testimonials that are exclusively negative without substantive description, or that could constitute defamation under Portuguese or EU law.
Because recommendations describe pregnancy, birth or postpartum experiences, they may contain health information. We process them with your explicit consent, as described in our Privacy Policy.
3. Ratings and Highlighted Qualities
Our submission form invites parents to rate various aspects of their experience. These ratings serve an editorial purpose: they help parents reflect on and articulate their experience, and they inform our internal moderation process.
Individual ratings are not published in the directory. They are used solely by our team to guide moderation decisions.
We may display a summary of qualities that parents have highlighted, for example: "Parents particularly valued: attentiveness, availability, respect for birth preferences." These tags are:
- Derived from aggregated responses, not from any individual submission
- Positive only: we do not display negative tags publicly
- Displayed only once a minimum threshold of recommendations has been reached, to ensure they reflect a genuine pattern rather than a single experience
4. Moderation Standards
All submitted recommendations are reviewed individually by a member of the Born to Be Wild team before publication. No recommendation is accepted or rejected automatically: each submission is read and assessed on its own merits. AI tools may help our team spot recommendations that need a closer look, but the decision is always taken by a person.
We will not publish content that:
- Contains personal insults, discriminatory language or harassment
- Makes unverifiable or clearly false factual claims
- Includes identifying information about third parties without their consent
- Appears to have been submitted in bad faith or as part of a coordinated campaign
- Is exclusively negative without any concrete descriptive element
We do not edit the substance of recommendations. If a submission requires more than minor formatting adjustments, we will contact the submitter before publishing. We aim to process submissions within 10 business days.
To make recommendations readable in both Portuguese and English, published texts may be translated, and their formatting tidied, with the help of AI tools. Translations are checked by our team and never change the meaning of what you wrote.
5. On Criticism and Nuance
We distinguish between:
- Statements of opinion ("I felt my concerns were not taken seriously"), which describe a subjective lived experience and are generally protected
- Statements presented as objective fact ("This practitioner did X"), which must be based on what the submitter genuinely experienced or observed
A critical or nuanced recommendation is not automatically rejected. What matters is that it reflects a real experience and contains enough concrete detail to be informative for other parents. We believe this kind of honest testimony is exactly what our community needs.
6. Practitioner Right of Response
Practitioners who have claimed their profile can post a short public reply under a published recommendation.
Any practitioner who believes a published recommendation contains inaccurate factual claims may also contact us to:
- Request a factual correction
- Submit a brief professional response to be published alongside the recommendation
- Request removal, with reasons
We will consider all such requests in good faith and aim to respond within 30 days.
Contact: hello@borntobewild.pt
7. Removal Requests
We will remove a recommendation if:
- The person who submitted it requests removal (you can also withdraw your consent to publication at any time)
- We determine upon review that it violates these standards
- A practitioner provides credible evidence that a specific factual claim is false
We will not remove a recommendation solely because it is critical, nuanced, or because a practitioner finds it unflattering.
Removal requests from submitters are processed within 5 business days. Requests from practitioners are processed within 30 days.
8. Directory Inclusion
Inclusion in the Born to Be Wild directory is an editorial decision. We do not apply automatic or purely numerical thresholds. Instead, we assess each practitioner's listing based on the overall picture provided by community submissions, including the number, consistency and substantive quality of recommendations received.
Where submissions raise recurring concerns, or where individual recommendations, though insufficient for publication on their own, suggest a pattern, we may contact submitters to better understand their experience before making a listing decision.
We reserve the right to decline to list, or to remove, any practitioner at our sole editorial discretion, without obligation to provide reasons. This decision is independent of whether individual recommendations about that practitioner are published.
9. No Paid Listings or Sponsored Recommendations
Born to Be Wild does not accept payment for listings, recommendations or any form of prioritisation in the directory. No practitioner can pay to appear, improve their ranking, or influence the publication of recommendations in any way. This policy is absolute.
Practitioners with an account on Born to Be Wild may update their professional profile. Like any visitor, they can read the recommendations published on their profile and reply to them, but they cannot edit, hide or remove recommendations, and they never see unpublished comments or individual ratings.
10. Transparency
We are committed to being transparent about how this directory works. If you have questions about how a recommendation was assessed or why a decision was made, you are welcome to contact us.
Contact: hello@borntobewild.pt