Home birth · Episode 15
A caesarean, a VBAC, then a home birth: Sara's three births in Portugal
An unplanned caesarean, a vacuum birth during COVID, then a home birth in her bathroom: Sara's three births, and how the last one brought her peace.
Born to be Wild · 2026-11-12
Sara grew up in France, moved to Lisbon in 2009 for her job as a flight attendant, and never imagined herself as a mother. Today she has three children, all born in Portugal, in three very different ways: an unplanned caesarean, a vacuum-assisted hospital birth, and a home birth. On episode 15 of the Born to be Wild podcast, she told Aviva Markowicz and Irene Jaspers how each birth prepared the next, and how the third one finally brought her peace.
First birth: an induction, then a caesarean nobody had prepared her for
Before her first pregnancy, Sara's plan was simple: an epidural, and feel nothing. A colleague's book about physiological birth planted a first seed of doubt. When she told her private obstetrician she was afraid of the pain, the answer was "don't worry, we'll book you a C-section". It felt wrong, and she changed doctors.
She prepared one-to-one with a French midwife and chose a public hospital near Lisbon known for supporting physiological birth. But in 2018 her son Jaime didn't want to come out:
- Past 41 weeks, the pressure to induce grew, with talk of a "big baby" and a "huge head". With her midwife's encouragement, she negotiated a few extra days, but eventually had to be induced.
- The induction ward had several women in one room, with no curtains and little privacy.
- Contractions came very fast and very intense. At 5 or 6 cm she asked for an epidural, then labour was slowed down with medication because the baby's heart rate reacted to the contractions.
- After a full day without food, her waters were broken the next morning, and half an hour later the team decided on a caesarean.
"I was feeling like when you are in the sea and you feel this current taking you and you just cannot do anything."
It wasn't an emergency, but her husband David was not allowed in the operating room. Sara almost fainted after the birth; Jaime was handed to David for skin-to-skin without anyone telling him how she was. Breastfeeding started well, but the weeks after were marked by a "bitter feeling of failure". A caesarean had never been part of her mental preparation.
Induction at or beyond 41 weeks is a decision to discuss with your care team: compared with waiting, it's associated with fewer perinatal deaths and fewer caesareans, though the absolute risks are small (Cochrane, 2020). Knowing your options in advance, including a possible caesarean, can help you feel less carried away by events.
Second birth: a VBAC in hospital, during COVID
When she became pregnant again, the first doctor she saw offered to schedule a second caesarean. Sara said no, and never went back. For most women with one previous caesarean, planning a vaginal birth after caesarean (VBAC) is a reasonable option, with around three in four succeeding (RCOG Green-top Guideline No. 45).
This time she prepared with doula Sara do Vale, whose support helped her trust that she could give birth "the normal way". Sara do Vale stayed with her at home in early labour so she could reach the hospital as late as possible. Because of COVID rules, the doula couldn't come in, and David had to wait four hours for a test result.
- A midwife on duty massaged and supported her and respected her wish to avoid an epidural.
- After about four hours, fully dilated, she was placed on her back and her daughter Amália was born with a vacuum (ventouse). The midwife had suggested an upright or seated position; the senior obstetrician refused. Lying on your back isn't necessary for birth: the WHO encourages women to choose the position they want, including upright positions (WHO, 2018; Cochrane, 2017).
- Sara still felt the rush of oxytocin she had missed the first time, and the midwife told her: "Never let anybody tell you that you cannot do it again."
It was a much better experience, but the instrumental birth felt violent, and that weighed on her postpartum.
Looking for support for a VBAC? Browse doulas and midwives in our directory, with reviews from other parents.
Third birth: a home birth, "non-negotiable"
Before her third pregnancy, Sara watched podcasts and talks that explained how hospital routines can create problems they then have to solve. With David, she decided: the third baby would be born at home. They saved for it, and found two home birth midwives, Filipa Piedade and Sandra Pedro.
How much does a home birth cost in Portugal? Sara's figures, from about a year ago:
- Around €2,700 for a full package, with preparation sessions, yoga and exercises, and several meetings with the midwives.
- Around €1,500 to €1,700 for a minimal package.
Prices vary between midwives, so ask what each package includes.
A week before the birth, a routine CTG at hospital showed she was already 4 cm dilated, but she felt nothing. She signed a discharge form and went home. The midwives came with the pool, nothing happened, and they went home too.
A week later, at around 40 weeks, she lost her mucus plug in the morning. Contractions started in the afternoon and became strong over dinner. Her mother took the children, and Sara went into the shower:
"I surrender. This is very intense. I cannot anymore."
Filipa arrived and held her. Sandra arrived a quarter of an hour before the birth. Sitting on the toilet, Sara felt the pushing reflex take over, without pain. The cord was around the baby's neck; the midwives calmly freed it, and with one more push, Joachim was born at home, about half an hour after the pushing started. She had pictured a water birth, but never saw herself in the pool: in the end she gave birth in her bathroom.
"It was just like fireworks in my head of happiness."
Three postpartums
Sara sums them up in a few words: the first was hard, with a sense of failure; the second was weighed down by a violent instrumental birth; the third was "just happiness", tired, but with an immediate bond with the baby and the whole family around.
What she would tell her younger self
- Learn the physiology of birth before the day.
- Be compassionate with yourself, before and after.
- Don't be angry at nature for the pain: see birth as a rite of passage.
- Choose the people around you. Continuous support during labour, from a midwife or doula, is associated with more spontaneous births and fewer caesareans (Cochrane, 2017).
"Please trust in yourself. Get the knowledge of the physiology, because it's very important."
Frequently asked questions
Can I have a vaginal birth after a caesarean? For most women with one previous caesarean and no other complications, yes. About three in four planned VBACs end in a vaginal birth. The main risk, uterine rupture, is rare (about 1 in 200) but serious, so discuss your situation with your care team (RCOG Green-top Guideline No. 45).
Is a home birth possible after a caesarean? Some midwives in Portugal accept a home birth after caesarean (HBAC), especially after a previous vaginal birth, as was the case for Sara. It depends on your history and on the midwife: ask early, and make sure there is a transfer plan.
Do I have to give birth lying on my back? No. The WHO recommends encouraging women to choose their position, including upright positions (WHO, 2018). You can write your preferred positions in your birth plan.
Sources
What our guests share comes from their own experience and practice. The medical and legal information in this article is based on the sources below. It doesn't replace advice from your care team.
- Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (2015). Birth After Previous Caesarean Birth. Green-top Guideline No. 45
- Middleton et al. (2020). Induction of labour at or beyond 37 weeks' gestation. Cochrane Review
- Gupta et al. (2017). Position in the second stage of labour for women without epidural anaesthesia. Cochrane Review
- World Health Organization (2018). WHO recommendations: intrapartum care for a positive childbirth experience
- Bohren et al. (2017). Continuous support for women during childbirth. Cochrane Review
Listen to the full episode
This article is based on episode 15 of Born to be Wild, the podcast: Sara, a C-section, a difficult VBAC, and finally giving birth on her own. Listen on Spotify.
Read also: What they (don't) tell you about giving birth in Portugal and Home birth in Portugal: what a midwife wants you to know.